A Virginia judge rejected TMZ’s emergency motion to intervene in Johnny Depp’s defamation case against Amber Heard on Wednesday, noting that her former employee appears to have chosen to testify on the Pirates of the Caribbean star’s name voluntarily.
“A party is not entitled to merely intervene because a byproduct of the litigation adversely impacts them,” Judge Penney Azcarate found.
Morgan Tremainea former reporter for the celebrity tabloid, appeared on a list of anticipated witnesses before Depp’s rebuttal case began on Tuesday.
“In this case, it appears that the witness is willing to state the name of the confidential source without being compelled voluntarily,” Azcarate said. “Whether that breached a nondisclosure agreement with Mr. Tremaine and [TMZ’s parent company] EHM is not germane to this matter and can be litigated in a separate matter if EHM so chooses. ”
Depp called him to testify about how TMZ came to acquire a confidential video of Depp yelling at Heard.
Late on Tuesday, TMZ moved to intervene and assert journalistic privilege.
“Journalists’ promises of confidentiality are vital to reporting the news,” TMZ’s attorneys wrote in a 7-page motion. “That is why the law strongly protects the ability of journalists to keep their promises. The Court should permit TMZ to keep the promise it made here. ”
The motion claims that Tremaine has no firsthand knowledge about the source of the footage.
During oral arguments, Depp’s lawyer took a shot at the celebrity tabloid, cracking that TMZ “isn’t exactly Edward R. Murrowyour honor, ”referring to the famous broadcast journalist and war correspondent.
TMZ’s lawyer Charles Tobin took umbrage at that remark.
“Obviously, the First Amendment applies to everybody, citizens, The New York Times and TMZ, ”Tobin said.
Depp’s attorney apologized for the remark, adding no “snarkiness” was intended.
“You’re just a snarky guy,” Azcarate quipped.
In an irony, TMZ — which regularly produces celebrity-related scoops — disclosed in its motion that it learned of Tremaine’s anticipated testimony from a competitor: Radar.
“According to the Radar Online report, [Depp] plans to elicit testimony from Mr. Tremaine regarding TMZ’s confidential source in an effort to ‘impeach’ the credibility of [Heard], ”The motion states. “Mr. Tremaine was a field assignment manager with TMZ at the time the article was published, but no longer works for the company. ”
Heard denied leaking the video on the witness stand.
TMZ had wanted to invoke privilege under California law (where it is headquartered) and Virginia law (where the trial is taking place).
“Virginia courts recognize a privilege, rooted in the First Amendment, protecting the relationship between journalists and their confidential sources and preventing those confidential sources from being outed in discovery or at trial,” the motion states.
Depp and Heard’s defamation cases landed in Fairfax County, Va., Where the washington post is printed. In 2018, Heard ran an op-ed in the Post stating that she “became a public figure representing domestic abuse” two years earlier, when she filed a restraining order against Depp in Los Angeles.
Heard countersued after Depp’s counsel called her claims a “hoax.”
(Photo by Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images)
Have a tip we should know? [email protected]